Mike Fulmer


Mike Fulmer, CLCS, is a graduate of West Muskingum High School and Ohio University. Mike began his insurance career with Monumental Life Insurance in 2006 focusing mainly on life insurance. In 2007 he joined the family business and expanded his focus into auto, home, farm and business insurance. In 2011 Mike obtained his Commercial Lines Coverage Specialist (CLCS) designation and completed State Auto’s prestigious Pacesetter program. Mike lends his expertise to the Muskingum County Business Incubator and Small Business Development Center advising new entrepreneurs on the potential risks of their new business ventures. Mike is a member of the North Terrace Church of Christ. Mike has served on many boards previously, including the American Cancer Society, Zanesville-Muskingum Chamber of Commerce and Taylor McHenry foundation. Mike currently serves as a board member with both the Zanesville Jaycees and the Jaycees Golf Course.

Mike currently resides in Zanesville with his wife Katie, son Moses and their dog, Levi. Mike’s hobbies include hiking, running, backpacking, golfing and DIY projects. Mike enjoys working with clients to develop a comprehensive insurance plan that fits their needs. He firmly believes that “Your Best Policy is a Good Agent!”


Katie Fulmer

Special Projects Coordinator


Taylor Wells


Taylor is a Florida native who moved to the Buckeye State in 2019. Zanesville has quickly become a place he gladly calls home. For the last 10 years, Taylor has been a youth minister and has recently made the jump to become a licensed insurance agent. He joined the Fulmer Insurance crew in September of 2023. He is a member of North Terrace Church of Christ where he loves playing bass guitar on the worship team, being a part of the A/V team, and even preaching on occasion.

Taylor loves spending time with his wife Brooke, daughter Addison, and their dog Jack. He enjoys watching sports, pretends that he’s good at some of them, being outside, grilling/smoking, and doing DIY projects of all kinds. Taylor believes that here at Fulmer Insurance, we can be here for you when you need us most, in the exciting moments and the not-so-exciting moments of life.


Kim Reed

Customer Service


After spending over twenty years as a life insurance agent, Ray Fulmer founded Fulmer Insurance in 1990 and began offering auto, home and business insurance. In 1994 the agency moved to its current location on McIntire Avenue. 

In 2006, Mike Fulmer began his insurance career as a life insurance agent. In 2007 Mike joined the agency and began offering auto, home and business insurance. In 2015, Mike purchased the agency and Ray semi-retired and began traveling in his RV. 

Much has changed over the years as the agency has grown, but our core principles remain the same. 


We strive to:

  • Be disciplined and purposeful

  • Educate our clients and empower them to make sound decisions

  • Innovate and communicate beyond our clients’ expectations

Ohio Insurance Agents Association member

Fulmer Insurance Agency

  • 733 McIntire Ave.

Zanesville, OH 43701

  • Hours:

8 am – 5 pm Monday-Friday

Baughman & Fulmer
Insurance Agency

  • 478 Main St.

Duncan Falls, OH 43734